I think if you leave u cant join anyother clan for so long and captain cant take other clan players whos in with m8 because it is get to be a joke

trouble is there zach is youll find a mass of people in limbo because they cant go to other clans,people leave clans for a reason.

disagree zac, players have the right to choose the clan they want to go to.

is this a GAME??

or am i mistaken are we all contracted to clans and what we do????

if a player wants to play for a different clan then so be it , who really cares aslong as ppl are happy and having fun as a GAME is suppose to be fun , we all have to abide by rules on this site to keep it a happy family site.

Now you want a rule to what players can do for fun on the game its pathetic, im a cptain just liek urself zach but if one of my players leave i support them in there venture and wish them luck as its all in the good of the game, some players like to move alot, for all sorts of reasons and some stay with the same clan for a very long time, but to try and make a rule that if a players leaves a clan on a GAME that they have to wait a while to join another is pathetic im sorry.

Keeping players isnt about how good of a captain you are its about how well as a group you get on within the clan, if someone doesnt feel like they fit in at a clan, then go join another, casuse if that will make it more fun for that particular individual then thats great!

not in support of this at all, and it wont be implemented as it cant be controlled

I actually agree with Zac on this one. Its pretty annoying trying to run a league when people are changing clans every few days. Perhaps introduce some sort of transfer system like Pool's?

This won't affect teams not involved in the league unless they try to sign from players that are involved.

wont be implemented, and if u ban teams from joining your league for transfers then you will have to ban them all by end of season.

If no one is going to take transfers seriously then the league is a waste of time. If you sign up for a league with a clan, you're committing yourself to being with that clan for at least a few weeks.

I have no problems with allowing a week long transfer window mid-season, as long as people don't transfer outside of the two windows.

i agree that restrictions should be put on players if we want the clan league to run properly,


at the moment players move from clan to clan because they can,

because there friend went or even because they prefer the picture,

players do not have to join a clan if they dont want to, so if the rules are stricter then thats the rules. players can choose to abide by the rules and join in if they wish.

so im with zac and iamtheworst ,

yes i agree with this deffo

iamtheworst

Ok i believe this idea isnt a bad one, probably wouldnt be that hard to implement, for league purposes only , but as this thread suggests as a full time rule this would be no good, for players in the league , yes i can agree with it, and if players do leave clans that are in the league then they should still be able to join other clans just maybe a season or 2 season long ban from the league this would be acceptable IMO, the transfer window for the league is a good idea as it is nice to keep ur 10-15 players that u enter, if ur clan is run brilliantly ppl will still leave for personal reasons or a mishap within the clan so the transfer window may come in useful.

I think lee and iamtheworst are right and i think if get so many people in it could happen

I've stickied this because I think its an important subject. What we need is a set list of rules that everyone is happy with, and this is the best way to come up with those.

I've already said my idea, so now its time for everybody to give theirs.

Rustythedog, I had no intention of trying to control transfers that aren't league related.

this is utter snipped id say i agree with rustythedog totally its all bout fun thats it its like zac is going on 2 serious on ere its not real life its a computer game

And if thats your attitude to everything, I pity you. But please try and keep this clean.

Edited by forum moderator iamtheworst, at 17:14 Thu 15/10/09 (BST)

look at it from the leagues perspective tho, ( bear in mind were all human and lots of effort goes in to running this for all to enjoy ) if a player moves he/she cant play for another team in the league till it finishes anyway,

so then the problem builds up, players in clans and they cant play in league, meaning less active players get put in and then the league slowly falls apart.

if players cant move clans when the clan league is running at least there is a guarentee of the best / most active players being involved and completion alot more likely.

i agree lee m8 to right spot on m8

I willing to run a transfer window thing and if clans dont go by it wil get 3/5 point off league each player and if its ok by ever captain

im not quoting who said what cuz thats time consuming but here is my two cents

there should be no laws on moving between 1 clan and another, as rusty said its about fun and enjoyment etc.

however, if you are part of a clan and are entered in a league with that clan then you shouldnt be allowed just leave and go to another clan straight away. so for clan league purposes only there should be a transfer window as mentioned above.

but in general most of the players that have been submitted for the clan leagues would be the best and most committed players anyway so it shouldnt be a major problem with players leaving.

i totally agree with the point rusty made that people stay in clans because they enjoy the team spirit and get on well with the other members and have fun with them.

As you pool clan league is great because players have every one know whaat there doing



Why dont we have a trail and after this season see how it is take things from there



is every bdy ok with that

why dont i go on pool later and find out how pool staff do this then ill post on here.

ye thats good