Clan League Discussion Thread
Viewing forum thread.
Back to Clan League Management.
Back to Forum List.
15:41 Tue 8 May 12 (BST) [Link]
ah the old days of clans
What seb said. Although I would suggest it simply being 1 point for the match win. That makes it best of 5 between the clans. On such a small number of frames, a 5-0 would basically end the contest.
ah the old days of clans
15:44 Tue 8 May 12 (BST) [Link]
Summary for captains:
In case of a tie at the top of the table at the end of the season, a playoff will be played with following format:
Both teams nominate 1 player for each game type. The matches will be a race to 3 in arc, reg, orig, carom and race to 2 in power.
Each match win gives your team 1 point. Whoever wins 3+ out of the 5 matches wins the league.
Comments or suggestions?
In case of a tie at the top of the table at the end of the season, a playoff will be played with following format:
Both teams nominate 1 player for each game type. The matches will be a race to 3 in arc, reg, orig, carom and race to 2 in power.
Each match win gives your team 1 point. Whoever wins 3+ out of the 5 matches wins the league.
Comments or suggestions?
15:46 Tue 8 May 12 (BST) [Link]
I've sent it to the captains so they can comment. Any point sending a message to damee lol?
15:47 Tue 8 May 12 (BST) [Link]
He'll see it if he shows up. No message for damee
Deleted User
(IP Logged)
(IP Logged)
17:30 Tue 8 May 12 (BST) [Link]
I'd have gone for results between tied teams deciding. But you couldn't implement that this season. (I dunno anything about fixtures and scores between teams)
Good old flip a coin or you could get the 2 captains together in a room to play rock, paper, scissors, lizard, spock.
Good old flip a coin or you could get the 2 captains together in a room to play rock, paper, scissors, lizard, spock.
17:36 Tue 8 May 12 (BST) [Link]
Yes but that doesn't work cos everyone always goes Spock .
Deleted User
(IP Logged)
(IP Logged)
21:06 Tue 8 May 12 (BST) [Link]
Personally I think its easier just to base it on the bonus table in the event of a tie.
Could then be used for 3rd and 4th or whatever then too
Could then be used for 3rd and 4th or whatever then too
Deleted User
(IP Logged)
(IP Logged)
21:56 Tue 8 May 12 (BST) [Link]
I think if you do that then the bonus table should only include League breaks. Otherwise some clans have an advantage as they have more games to hit bonuses in.
All this discussion, it probably won't end up a tie anyway
All this discussion, it probably won't end up a tie anyway
21:59 Tue 8 May 12 (BST) [Link]
Yeah, bonus table can't be used in its current form- clans with defaults and not in cup/plate final are at a disadvantage.
It's not just for this season. We should have some sort of pre-agreed tiebreaker in place just in case it happens in any season.
It's not just for this season. We should have some sort of pre-agreed tiebreaker in place just in case it happens in any season.
22:17 Tue 8 May 12 (BST) [Link]
Sounds good for this season. Unlikely it would happen in anycase.
Summary for captains:
In case of a tie at the top of the table at the end of the season, a playoff will be played with following format:
Both teams nominate 1 player for each game type. The matches will be a race to 3 in arc, reg, orig, carom and race to 2 in power.
Each match win gives your team 1 point. Whoever wins 3+ out of the 5 matches wins the league.
Comments or suggestions?
In case of a tie at the top of the table at the end of the season, a playoff will be played with following format:
Both teams nominate 1 player for each game type. The matches will be a race to 3 in arc, reg, orig, carom and race to 2 in power.
Each match win gives your team 1 point. Whoever wins 3+ out of the 5 matches wins the league.
Comments or suggestions?
Sounds good for this season. Unlikely it would happen in anycase.
07:52 Wed 9 May 12 (BST) [Link]
maybe do what football league do and look at who won the match between them in that season, or use the bonus league, or take off bonus points and see who has most frames then?????
just a few ideas incase some people didnt lke the current format, i do but some may not
just a few ideas incase some people didnt lke the current format, i do but some may not
Deleted User
(IP Logged)
(IP Logged)
10:50 Wed 9 May 12 (BST) [Link]
Playoff! Playoff! Playoff!! Add some drama to it! It's meant to be fun after all!
12:49 Wed 9 May 12 (BST) [Link]
been discussed already and flaws for each of them
maybe do what football league do and look at who won the match between them in that season, or use the bonus league, or take off bonus points and see who has most frames then?????
just a few ideas incase some people didnt lke the current format, i do but some may not
just a few ideas incase some people didnt lke the current format, i do but some may not
been discussed already and flaws for each of them
14:14 Wed 9 May 12 (BST) [Link]
Not exactly. The direct matchup during the season could be used- no problems with that. The other two do have flaws.
But so far I think more people are favoring the playoff.
But so far I think more people are favoring the playoff.
18:47 Sun 13 May 12 (BST) [Link]
Right time for my idea...
I am looking to do another side event for league similar to Bonus League + Highest Break but this would only be an individual competition.
my idea is to see how many halfs, cents and maxes each person can make in a season and whoever gets most is the winner
Halfs are counted as 50-99 (Arc, Reg, Orig), 5-9 (Carom) and 100-149 (Power)
Cents are counted as 100+ (Arc, Reg, Orig), 10-14 (Carom) and 150-199 (Power)
Maxes are counted as 107 (Arc) 147 (Reg, Orig), 15+ (Carom) and 200+ (Power)
For each Half you make you will get +1 on Half Section
For each Cent you make you will get +1 on Half and Cent Section
For each Max you make you will get +1 on Half, Cent and Max Section
I am also looking to see what highest break people can get for each game mode (this isn't a competition but purely stat based) in a season and in clan leagues, note that we won't go digging up previous breaks so its up to you if you want to find your true highest break but would start from next season.
this hasn't been implemented yet so i just want to know peoples thoughts
I am looking to do another side event for league similar to Bonus League + Highest Break but this would only be an individual competition.
my idea is to see how many halfs, cents and maxes each person can make in a season and whoever gets most is the winner
Halfs are counted as 50-99 (Arc, Reg, Orig), 5-9 (Carom) and 100-149 (Power)
Cents are counted as 100+ (Arc, Reg, Orig), 10-14 (Carom) and 150-199 (Power)
Maxes are counted as 107 (Arc) 147 (Reg, Orig), 15+ (Carom) and 200+ (Power)
For each Half you make you will get +1 on Half Section
For each Cent you make you will get +1 on Half and Cent Section
For each Max you make you will get +1 on Half, Cent and Max Section
I am also looking to see what highest break people can get for each game mode (this isn't a competition but purely stat based) in a season and in clan leagues, note that we won't go digging up previous breaks so its up to you if you want to find your true highest break but would start from next season.
this hasn't been implemented yet so i just want to know peoples thoughts
| Unable to post | |
|---|---|
| Reason: | You must log in before you can post |
Clan League Discussion Thread
Back to Top of this Page
Back to Clan League Management.
Back to Forum List.