Clan League Discussion Thread
Viewing forum thread.
Back to Clan League Management.
Back to Forum List.
17:00 Sun 9 Oct 11 (BST) [Link] Just want to make sure everyone is aware: If all clans make it through, that's 15 fixtures for all players. That's 105 games to be played total. If this is run, we should make sure a majority are played.
Edited at 16:07 Sun 09/10/11 (BST)
whocares8x8 said:
Probably best if we contact all captains and vices to see if they would want to play:
whocares8x8 - yes
dgeneratio - yes
damee - yes
jay_afc - ???
_nut_case_ - ???
slatty - ???
ang_k - yes
davey1985 - yes
i_am_god - yes
??? (hustler's vice) - ???
hughsy89 - yes
mr_explosive - yes
dunkyfunk - ???
trickshotz - ???
copper10 - ???
jenni - ???
whocares8x8 - yes
dgeneratio - yes
damee - yes
jay_afc - ???
_nut_case_ - ???
slatty - ???
ang_k - yes
davey1985 - yes
i_am_god - yes
??? (hustler's vice) - ???
hughsy89 - yes
mr_explosive - yes
dunkyfunk - ???
trickshotz - ???
copper10 - ???
jenni - ???
Edited at 16:07 Sun 09/10/11 (BST)
17:06 Sun 9 Oct 11 (BST) [Link]
explosive said yes.
all starz looking rather gloomy atm.
all starz looking rather gloomy atm.
Deleted User
(IP Logged)
(IP Logged)
18:17 Sun 9 Oct 11 (BST) [Link]
i like the idea because im guessing the captains and vices get there games done straight away so were sitting around a week or so doing nothing, it gives us something else to look forward to... i dnt mind helping out also but i think u do a good enough job urself :)
23:21 Wed 12 Oct 11 (BST) [Link]
If there are rules which anyone believes need changing, bring them up here and now, so that they can be talked about and implemented for next season.
adam mentioned the completion bonus system before and we reached no conclusion yet.
Anything else?
Current rules are here:
http://funkysnookerclanleague.freeforums.org/clan-league-rules-t9.html
adam mentioned the completion bonus system before and we reached no conclusion yet.
Anything else?
Current rules are here:
http://funkysnookerclanleague.freeforums.org/clan-league-rules-t9.html
23:23 Wed 12 Oct 11 (BST) [Link]
just the bonus league but settled i think.
23:24 Wed 12 Oct 11 (BST) [Link]
Yeah, bonus league will be changed.
I'm thinking more about the rules that affect the league.
I'm thinking more about the rules that affect the league.
19:23 Thu 13 Oct 11 (BST) [Link]
You should know the one rule I don't like is the conceding rule. Yes I agree we should encourage all games to be completed but I just want to tweak that rule slightly.
Basically, if a player concedes for one team and all the other games are completed, then the team who didn't concede get the 10 bonus fixture points while the other don't, due to the concession?
Basically, if a player concedes for one team and all the other games are completed, then the team who didn't concede get the 10 bonus fixture points while the other don't, due to the concession?
19:29 Thu 13 Oct 11 (BST) [Link]
im so glad this site isnt like pool...
19:30 Thu 13 Oct 11 (BST) [Link]
if we do do that then we would have to change it from 10 points for no defaults to something else.
i don't mind which way we go but i put an idea about 5 points for those
damee said:
You should know the one rule I don't like is the conceding rule. Yes I agree we should encourage all games to be completed but I just want to tweak that rule slightly.
Basically, if a player concedes for one team and all the other games are completed, then the team who didn't concede get the 10 bonus fixture points while the other don't, due to the concession?
Basically, if a player concedes for one team and all the other games are completed, then the team who didn't concede get the 10 bonus fixture points while the other don't, due to the concession?
if we do do that then we would have to change it from 10 points for no defaults to something else.
i don't mind which way we go but i put an idea about 5 points for those
19:31 Thu 13 Oct 11 (BST) [Link]
If it's only the last fixture? the last 2 fixtures? the last 3 fixtures? We almost had that scenario in your games against Attacking Super Stars right?
I strongly believe that all unplayed frames must go to the default team. Bonus points are given for leaving the fixture with no defaults. It's a joint effort by both teams.
I would rather get rid of the completion bonus completely, if it creates trouble.
Edited at 16:36 Thu 13/10/11 (BST)
I strongly believe that all unplayed frames must go to the default team. Bonus points are given for leaving the fixture with no defaults. It's a joint effort by both teams.
I would rather get rid of the completion bonus completely, if it creates trouble.
Edited at 16:36 Thu 13/10/11 (BST)
Deleted User
(IP Logged)
(IP Logged)
19:38 Thu 13 Oct 11 (BST) [Link]
Perhaps if unplayed games are only due to concession and are supported by screenshots of some sort then half the bonus points to 5?
19:43 Thu 13 Oct 11 (BST) [Link]
If the majority of people want this, then I'll go along as well (although I still prefer the other way).
If the player posts that he is conceding, then the 5 points can go to the other team. That player will of course still get the usual punishment for conceding.
If the player posts that he is conceding, then the 5 points can go to the other team. That player will of course still get the usual punishment for conceding.
21:00 Thu 13 Oct 11 (BST) [Link]
Yeah that is fair enough, I've given up on scrapping the not-conceding rule and thought that would be fair enough.
But if it's saying at 10 bonus points for fixture set complete, but if 1 match is finished by concession, then why should the team who didn't concede get punished by losing an extra 5 bonus points?
But yeah, clearly punish that person or clan (if they have a few offenders who do it) who concede though.
But if it's saying at 10 bonus points for fixture set complete, but if 1 match is finished by concession, then why should the team who didn't concede get punished by losing an extra 5 bonus points?
But yeah, clearly punish that person or clan (if they have a few offenders who do it) who concede though.
21:00 Thu 13 Oct 11 (BST) [Link]
Just get rid of it for me, clans should not be penalised by another clan not completing fixtures. Not being able to get full bonus points is being penalised. 5 is not 10 so the clan is still being penalised.
21:21 Thu 13 Oct 11 (BST) [Link]
Quick idea for individual league, give the last 4 from each season seedings in the next competition, so they shouldn't face each other?
21:24 Thu 13 Oct 11 (BST) [Link]
its not a bad shout.
FCL cup on pool used to be seeded as much as possible as jan tried to match div 1 teams to play div 2 teams in the cup so the 2nd division gets a feel whats its like playing a div 1 team.
FCL cup on pool used to be seeded as much as possible as jan tried to match div 1 teams to play div 2 teams in the cup so the 2nd division gets a feel whats its like playing a div 1 team.
21:28 Thu 13 Oct 11 (BST) [Link]
I can seed 4 players for the first round if you want, but other than that it's designed with the same idea as the FA Cup- you an face anyone at any time.
Cup- mooney (created the cup in this format) wanted it to be as random as possible, so I'm not really in favor of seeding there either.
Cup- mooney (created the cup in this format) wanted it to be as random as possible, so I'm not really in favor of seeding there either.
21:30 Thu 13 Oct 11 (BST) [Link]
either that or final 4 should be first to get byes in rd 1 if there are any???
21:32 Thu 13 Oct 11 (BST) [Link]
yeah, i'll figure something like that out when we get participants in a couple of weeks.
Unable to post | |
---|---|
Reason: | You must log in before you can post |
Clan League Discussion Thread
Back to Top of this Page
Back to Clan League Management.
Back to Forum List.