Cup...

2 groups of 3

Play each other once. (3/6 weeks depending on deadline)

Top 2 go straight to Cup semi finals.

2nd in group A play 3rd in group B (Winner plays winner of Group B)
2nd in group B play 3rd in group A (Winner plays winner of Group A)(another week or 2 each)

Losers of both play off games can play each other in plate Final
At the same time the Other 2 semi's are played.

Winners play each other in Final
Losers play 3rd and 4th place playoff.

(Plate final can be put off til date of the final.)

Just a suggestion.

That sounds nice as well. We wouldn't play the 3rd/4th place playoff, because those games didnt get played in the past since nobody cared.

What happens if we get 7 teams?

Then you go for a different format.

whoever is last is eliminated?

^Yeah, but that means they're just sitting around while the rest are playing. I want to keep as many teams as possible involved, which is why groups are appealing.

You misunderstand I think. You are perfectly free to arrange your own time with your opponents and are encouraged to do so. It can be played anytime!
But for those who don't want to bother arranging (almost half by the end of last season), the predetermined times make it easier.

Yer but I can gurantee that most clans will say let's wait tilll the arranged time. Its impossible to know if your gonna have players on at that set time.

True. Isn't it the same with Sundays at 9 last season though?

Players did have (in this case) 9 or 10 days advance notice about the killer times and they could've been rearranged for another time!

But anyway, we'll see how the rest go and then continue from there.

Although I agree that the set times aren't working, the one thing we can't say is that no notice was given.

I posted the times for each game at the beginning of the fixture set, so people had about 10 days to prepare for their killer times or to try to rearrange with the opposing clan.

The killer games won't count towards the preseason friendlies, so clan have to complete 16/18 games to guarantee entry to the season.

Although there is 1 killer game left tomorrow, I think it's fair to say that the idea hasn't quite worked out.

There are now two options with the season beginning soon.

1) Killer stays the same as last season.

2) Killer is removed completely.

Vote please!

Same as last season

Although I am most probably not going to participate this season I would remove it completely.

I enjoy clan killer, but arranging it isn't very fun

Scrap it!

Keep killler as it was last season but don't limit it to 3v3,


I feel if we scrap killer we are taking a step back instead of moving forward.

Edited at 09:18 Mon 25/03/13 (GMT)

Scrap it and add a second power game...why only one , we have 2 of the funny game with no pockets that no one plays lol.



Killer is fun but causes too much grief...even within teams let alone between teams.

Scrap it.

Kili has a good idea there, second power game added would be good also i think.

But reduces possible subs to 6. better 2 power and only one carom

Scrap killer. Nightmare to arrange and the old system didn't work as it was too easy to exploit by teams leaving it till deadline day if they didn't have their best 3 on.

Second power would be good but would need to wait for next season and increase team size to 17 as 6 subs for 10 games is harsh.

Increase team size just now lol lol

We would have to go back through all the pre-season friendlies to do that! Plus, it wasn't long ago that we were discussing reducing clan sizes to get more clans... Anyway, we should discuss this after so it doesn't mess sebs vote up!